The 1911 is one of the most legendary firearms in existence.
It’s been around since the year 1911 and found its way into wars and conflicts all across the planet.
Today, it remains one of the most popular firearms ever produced for a variety of uses.
You can find 1911s for $350 all the way to $4,000 custom guns. It’s truly mind-blowing to look and see how much the 1911 varies in price.
Many of us may not want to spend more than $500-$800 on a 1911. This article is for those people, the people looking for affordable, or dare I say, cheap 1911s?
THE QUICK LIST
-
Best Budget 1911
-
Best Budget Carry 1911
-
Editor’s Pick
-
Best Features
-
Best Budget 10mm 1911
-
Best For Plinking
Table of Contents
Loading…
How We Chose The Best Budget 1911s
Input into this article came from the PPT editorial team and our writers. Together we have a combined shooting experience of 30+ years, including instruction, competition, and multiple shooting disciplines.
Every gun on this list has been handled and tested by someone here at PPT. To properly assess these 1911s, we put at least 500 rounds through them at 3, 7, and 10 yards. We use both practice and self-defense ammo to ensure reliability.
We’ve spent countless hours researching and analyzing to determine which is the best when it comes to features, reliability, ergonomics, and bang for your buck.
We had to make some tough calls. If you don’t see your favorite 1911, it doesn’t mean we hate it, just that we couldn’t include it this time.
What to Expect with a Wallet-Friendly 1911
The 1911 can be a cranky platform. But can you blame it? It’s over a century old.
Its old-school design came from a time when craftsmanship was a thing. Guns were fitted together versus mass-produced on assembly lines.
Your standard, mass-produced 1911 can have issues…especially when it comes to tight tolerances. This can come in the form of jams, failures to extract, failures to feed specific ammo, and more.
Is this a more significant issue with cheap 1911s?
In our experience, no, not really. Between the team here at Pew Pew Tactical, we have handled a good chunk of budget 1911s, and by in large, they run very well.
It used to be that most affordable 1911s were no-frills stripped-down models. But recently, nicer features such as Novak cut sights, ambi-safeties, adjustable triggers, nicer beavertails, and fancy grips are becoming more commonplace on budget 1911s.
Most will be chambered .45 ACP, but 9mm and 10mm options are becoming increasingly popular. You can usually expect to get a mag or two as well.
Best Sub-$500 1911s
1. Tisas 1911 A1 – Best Budget 1911
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Tisas 1911 A1 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Extremely affordable
- All forged parts
- Good fit and finish
- Minimal rollmarks
Cons
- GI-style sights are hard to use
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Barrel length: 5″
- Weight: 37 oz
- Capacity: 7+1
We are going to come out of the gate swinging with our favorite team pick here — the SDS Imports Tisas 1911 A1.
While Rock Island Armory long held the spot for the best bang-for-your-buck classic GI gun, Tisas has just upped the game.
For those that don’t know, many entry-level 1911s use the casting process to create their frames and use metal injection molding (MIM) to make small parts like control levers and triggers.
While you can have good casting and MIM parts, forged frames and machined steel parts are flat-out superior. Tisas forges all their frames, and they use zero MIM parts with the sole exception of the recoil spring plug.
Considering these guns only cost $300-$350, I didn’t believe it, but sure enough, it is right on their website!
Aside from that, these GI-style guns have excellent build quality, good triggers, nice finish, and they come with two sets of grips (one plastic, one wood), two magazines, and a barrel bushing tool.
These run exceedingly well and are the best value in 1911s right now and are perfect for those who just want to dip their toes in the pool.
Check out our complete review of the Tisas 1911 A1 or our video below!
2. Rock Island Armory Standard FS Nickel – Best Budget Govt. 1911
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Rock Island Armory Standard FS Nickel Pros & Cons
Pros
- Nice matte nickel finish
- Ambi safety and extended beavertail under $500
- Skeletonized hammer and trigger
Cons
- No front serrations
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Barrel length: 5″
- Weight: 40 oz
- Capacity: 8+1
Rock Island Armory’s long-term commitment to providing quality 1911s at a reasonable price is a big part of the reason that other companies have followed suit and the market is as good as it is today.
For those wanting to step up from the small GI sights and older-style hammer and trigger, look no further than the RIA Standard FS.
This true “government” model features a skeletonized hammer and trigger, Novak-style sights, an ambidextrous safety, an extended beavertail, G10 grips, and a nice matte nickel finish.
All of this comes in at around $450-$500, making this an excellent choice for those that want a more modern-optioned stainless 1911 without breaking the bank.
You can check our full review of the RIA GI 1911.
3. Tisas 1911 Devil Ray Carry – Best Budget Carry 1911
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Tisas 1911 Devil Ray Carry Pros & Cons
Pros
- Contoured frame for concealed carry
- Front slide serrations
- Grips relief cut for mag release
Cons
- No front strap checkering
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Barrel length: 4.25″
- Weight: 32 oz
- Capacity: 8+1
Tisas once again makes the list with a great offering in their 1911 Devil Ray Carry model.
You get nice, easy-to-see Novak-style sights, forward slide serrations, and the piece-de-resistance, an Ed Brown Signature bobtail frame cut to help with concealability at the grip.
Other features include an ambidextrous safety, extended beavertail, and textured grips with a relief cut for easier access to the magazine release.
Being a carry model means the barrel is 4.25 inches long (commander-length), and the frame is slightly cut with melted corners for easy, comfortable carry.
Coming in at right around $500, the Devil Ray Carry offers a lot of features commonly found on high-end 1911s. Its commander-length slide and bobtail grip profile make this an appealing option for those looking to potentially concealed carry a 1911 on a budget.
What do you think of the Tisas? Rate it below!
Best Mid-Range 1911s
4. Springfield Armory Garrison – Editor’s Pick
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Springfield Garrison Pros & Cons
Pros
- Very accurate
- Gorgeous hot salt blued finish
- Tight fitment
- Great trigger
Cons
- No front strap checkering
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Barrel length: 4.25″ – 5″
- Weight: 33 oz – 37 oz
- Capacity: 7+1
So you want a bit of a step-up maybe in both name and quality, while still staying under a grand? Check out the Springfield Garrison.
The Garrison is available in either stainless or in an amazing hot salt-blued finish. Features include a 5-inch match-grade barrel, low-profile 3-dot sights, backstrap checkering, and a skeletonized trigger and hammer.
These guns feel more akin to a higher-end $1500 1911, yet they will only set you back about $750-$850 or so. They are available in 9mm and .45 ACP.
You are going to get a beautiful gun with a good trigger that runs well out of the box. This is one of our favorite picks overall.
Be sure to check out our full hands-on review of the Garrison!
5. Fusion Freedom Reaction – Best Features
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Fusion Freedom Reaction Pros & Cons
Pros
- Target crowned barrel
- Front slide serrations and front strap checkering
- Great trigger
Cons
- No option for an accessory rail
Specs
- Caliber: .45 ACP
- Barrel length: 5″
- Weight: 39 oz
- Capacity: 8+1
Although you may not have heard of Fusion Firearms, they know their stuff.
The company was founded by the former president of Dan Wesson and has been producing frames, barrels, and other 1911 parts for some time.
Their Freedom Series Government model includes aggressive front strap checkering, front cocking serrations, fiber front sight, target crowned muzzles, and an excellent trigger.
Even though these do cost a bit more, coming in around $750, the build quality on these is outstanding, and it still very much represents a value-buy.
Tight fitment, smooth coatings, and a lack of machining marks give this gun more of a semi-custom feel rather than a production gun.
Best Non-.45 Budget 1911s
6. Girsan MC1911 S Hunter – Best Budget 10mm 1911
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
Girsan MC1911 S Hunter Pros & Cons
Pros
- Fully adjustable rear sight
- Affordable for a long slide 1911
- Accessory rail
- Harder hitting 10mm
Cons
- Trigger is solid but not outstanding
Specs
- Caliber: 10mm
- Barrel length: 6″
- Weight: 51.2 oz
- Capacity: 8+1
Sometimes you just need to go bigger. And by bigger, I mean both in caliber and size.
Girsan has you covered with their awesome MC1911 S Hunter, a 6-inch barreled long slide 1911 in the heavy-hitting 10mm.
Despite its imposing presence, the price on the Hunter isn’t nearly as scary — clocking in at around $600-$650.
An ambi safety, fully adjustable rear “super sight,” forward serration, accessory rail, extended beavertail, and G10 grips ensure that the Hunter is ready for the field and delivers smooth shooting at the range.
The overall quality on these is solid, and if you want to get into a big-boy 1911, this is the cheapest way to do it.
7. ATI GSG 1911-22 – Best for Plinking
Prices accurate at time of writing
Prices accurate at time of writing
-
25% off all OAKLEY products - OAKLEY25
Copied! Visit Merchant
ATI GSG 1911-22 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Cheap to shoot
- Affordable
- Ultra low recoil
Cons
- Requires more cleaning and decent ammo to run reliably
Specs
- Caliber: .22LR
- Barrel length: 5″
- Weight: 34.4 oz
- Capacity: 10+1
During ammo droughts, I lean a lot on .22LR. I stock it throughout the year and always have a pile on hand, just in case.
.22 is a fun cartridge that’s easy to shoot; it’s perfect for training, new shooters, and young shooters. Obviously, 1911s in .22 exist, and one of the most affordable is the GSG 1911-22.
This little fella is a simple blowback firearm that tends to cycle reliably as long as it’s kept clean.
Unsurprisingly, .22LR tends to be dirty, so CLP is required to keep the 1911-22 running.
Various models exist with fake suppressors, threaded barrels, rails, ambi safeties, extended beavertails, and more.
These little guys also tend to be extremely affordable, and affordable is the name of the game today.
It’s a great stand-in for your centerfire 1911 and grants the gun a much cheaper course of ammunition.
The little GSG 1911-22s are a blast to shoot, fit most standard 1911 holsters, and are compatible with a wide variety of 1911 parts like grips.
On top of that, the 10-round magazines are affordable and easy to find. This is perfect for a budget 1911 and a perfect choice as a fun .22LR handgun for plinking.
Final Thoughts
The 1911 is a fun platform. An all-metal design, the single-action trigger, and the big ole’ .45 ACP (or other cartridges) all come together to make something uniquely American.
And the good news is 1911s don’t have to cost an arm and a leg. They certainly can, but you have a ton of different options at almost any price range.
If you are just looking for a fun gun for the range or the collection, I wouldn’t hesitate with a more affordable 1911 option.
Do you have any experience with any of these? Are there any we missed? Let us know in the comments! A gun is great and all, but don’t forget mags! See our top recommendations at the Best 1911 Mags: .45 ACP & 9mm.
Latest Updates
August 2024: Replaced Rock Island Standard FS with Rock Island Standard FS Nickel model.
95 Leave a Reply
I got the Girsan 1911MC officers model in 9mm for about $530 and it was great. Not without its problems; the firing pin stop was too big and needed to be pounded out with a punch and a hammer, and sanded down to fit right, and the plunger spring was bent. But for 530? I absolutely love it and my other pistols are getting jealous of all the attention I am spending on this thing.
Somehow cheap is equated with inexpensive.
There’s nothing inexpensive about a firearm that doesn’t work at all, doesn’t work properly, or is prone to fail for one reason or another. Many inexpensive 1911s need considerable re-work to function reliably, as the reason why their price is so low is that corners are cut in poor materials, shoddy manufacture, inept/inadequate design, or little or no quality control/assurance.
If it costs several hundreds of dollars for one of these pistols to be brought up to a level of a Colt 1911, as an arbitrary choice, what has been gained…?
It’s too bad that there’s no objective rating of firearms. As well-meaning as someone’s opinions might be, there are significant drawbacks to opinions — where a formal system of testing and evaluation, and tracking of deficiencies might be more appropriate. I recall years ago a NRA publication extolling the virtues of a new shotgun — which, due to its significant deficiencies, sold less than 40 units before the company folded.
Caveat emptor.
Any thoughts on the GSG vs the Walter Colt?
Thanks for the superb analyses of these 1911 models as they helped me narrow my selection down greatly and saved a lot of time.
The 1911, nothing will stir up more arguments then this classic work. No matter who you are and experience level, everyone has a strong opinion of these guns. I'm no expert, but I've been in the gun world 40+ years and shot everything imaginable. So when I say the TISAS Service Special is the very best 1911 value going today, I can back it up. Naturally the 1911 is an American classic with a rich history, so many afficionados rate any foreign clone below what is made here. But to start out, what can $350 buy in the 1911 world today? Even models a few more hundred dollars can be compared, but none are better than the TISAS Service Special in that low price range. You have to give the Turks a lot of credit. They take a serious approach to making modern guns with ultra-modern equipment and low labor costs. The Service Special is a breathtaking example of the original GI classic. Any gun is only as good as it feeds and fires accurately. I have repeatedly tested it against my SIG P220 Legion, SIG 1911 STX, and SIG P245. All guns fire without a single malfunction and the tight groups of the TISAS compare very favorably to the SIG's. Isn't that what we ultimately want any gun to do? Over the decades, I have seen and shot many guns with painstaking handmade precision from master gunsmiths and totally machine made versions. In the past, if you wanted the absolute very best, handmade was the only way to go. Technology is constantly improving and today's CNC machined guns are rivaling the best efforts from old school gunsmiths. This will only get better as time goes on. So the choice is yours to spend thousands on long hours of skilled craftsman's labor who will eventually not be able to compete with the best machinery.
I live on the left coast and just a few days ago checked the California pistol roster and Tisas in not on it. (yet)
A bit late to the party but are any of these pre-drilled and tapped for red dots?
I never even heard of Tisas until I shot my nephew's 1911. I was impressed all around. It's not as good as my Magnum Research 1911G that's about 12 years old, but It's on my list of things that I want.
A bit late to the party but are any of these pre-drilled and tapped for red dots?
no
I grew up shooting a 1911 45 and until a couple years ago, I never even considered carrying a 1911 or a wheel gun for my CCW. I love the list and have been looking at TISAS, there's two budget 1911's that I didn't see on the list, the Taurus PT1911, and oddly enough the PSA 1911 at Palmetto State Armory,their GI Model is under 350, though I haven't had one before they're definitely base model mil spec 1911's. The gun I carry daily now is a Beretta 92X 18+1 round 9mm. Unlike most people I prefer a heavy full size pistol, because a heavy old 1911 shoots much easier for me than a polymer anything. The 1911 absorbs a lot of recoil without much transfer to my wrists...I've shot a few different polymer guns and they're just ridiculous, i tried a compact 9mm sig and it was crazy how much felt recoil I was getting. For me personally I wouldn't stake my life on one if I had a choice to take a 1911 instead. My bud let me try out his old Beretta 92FS when we were target shooting a couple years ago. He said he had a 9mm he wanted me to try, I wasn't interested because I thought it was gonna be a glockenspiel, but he handed me that steel frame 92 and said the first pull was double action, but then was single action for the rest of the shots. That first pull felt like a mile long but I pinged my plate target on the first shot and told him that was a long pull, the single action trigger was nice and crisp though just like a 1911. People say that the 1911 is obsolete in the ccw world today but l don't believe that for a second. They say the capacity is too limited, and they weigh a ton. I don't see the capacity as an issue, I always have an 8 round in the pistol for ease of concealment, and always have a round chambered, then I got three 10 round backup mags. I see the point in more bullets is better, but personally not if it comes at sacrificing my accuracy being a cost to get more rounds. The 1911 will always be my hands down favorite pistol platform and I'll take a heavy ass, limited capacity, time tested, World War Winning 45acp that I can run ten times more effectively than anything else. I handload all my target and SD Loads, and in the 45 I always have my Federal Hydra-Shok 235 grain HP's, if I can't find those I got Hornady Critical Duty in my 1911's.
Not even close. By far the best entry level 1911 you can buy right now is the Charles Daly built by Brixia in Italy it has the proof marks for over pressure testing every barrel. They are built on the same machinery used to built the Valtro 1989.
I am not a pistol person but I recently purchased a tisas 1911 carry ($329 +tax)in 45 acp
And the gun is tight but runs great and is easy to control. Still in the break-in count but have only 1 failure and that was 1st or 2 nd shot it eats fmj and self defense ammo. I would like to find a commander in same price range in 9mm.
Ahhhhhhhhhh, yet another recycled old article. What's the ratio of new to old/barely updated piece's? 1:20? 1:30?
We regularly update older content and push it to the top to allow newer readers to have an opportunity to catch up. We do update these with newer recommendations or models we've tested. Thanks for reading.
Haters gonna hate
I have owned 1911 models from Colt, Ruger, Springfield, and Kimber. In 45, 9mm, and in 10mm. They are heavy, low capacity, and not super reliable. Nothing however shoots like a 1911. Its like driving an old car or truck with a manual transmission. Something satisfying about it. While my other 1911 models eventually got sold, I love and frequently shoot my gsg in .22 lr. It goes bang every time, very accurate out to 35+ yards and eats supermaximum ammo. Love it.
Glad to hear your GSG runs well! .22s can be a little finicky, but that is awesome that you have one that works so well.
When I retired last year, the officers at my agency gifted me a Garrison. They had a gunsmith install an ambi safety and had it engraved (name, rank, years of service). It is such a nice handgun, and it shoots really nice. You can't beat that 1911 trigger. I recommend it to anyone interested in getting a 1911.
Sean, I completely agree. The Garrisons look amazing, especially given the price. Glad you enjoy yours!
A friend of mine bought a Tina's 1911 in 9mm for a little over $300.00.
Frankly, when he told me what he paid for it, I wasn't expecting much. But, much to my surprise, it was one nice gun. While I didn't have a chance to live fire it, I did rack the slide and pull the trigger. Both were smooth; very nice. For $300+, this is a great 1911.
I was in the same boat, I didn't expect that much. Like you, I was surprised by the quality and the fitment. If you have a chance to shoot it, you should give it a go!
The Friend I referred to is a "Collecter" of sorts. He has almost 50 guns in his collection but only 5 or so has he live fired. But he does a lot of dry firing. :)
I had always wanted a full size .22 / 1911. First time I tried to order an ATI GSG, the order was rejected. The state of Illinois deemed the firearm unsafe because of the poor quality alloy the gun was made of. Apparently, there was some history of them blowing up. This was some years back, but I don’t think it has been taken off the prohibition list. Since then, I purchased a Colt Ace .22 conversion unit for my Colt Govt. model. Works great, but I can’t find any extra mags for it that don’t cost an arm or other body part.
I have carried and shot my ATI 4" 1911 GI for a few years now and it has never failed me. I have put a Wilson Combat firing pin,extended slide release and safety lever and done a trigger polish. I run Wilson Combat mags too. It has always gone bang when i press the trigger
That was built by SAM they build in house now the moxie it is a poly frame. They don't build steel frame anymore
I can’t believe Bul Armory isn’t part of this discussion they are setting the new standard for 1911’s under $1000
John, BUL armory makes some great guns. Their base models start at about $750, which was about our max for this article. As always, to keep the list short, we had to make some tough cuts. Hopefully we can get a SAS II UL in for review sometime soon.
Wyatt, that is true. The Sas2 UL has been reviewed to death. If you want to have some fun try getting the SAS 2 TAC 4.25 pro model that is ported with a steel frame. That would be a lot more fun to shoot. I’m still waiting for mine. It’s in jail in New York. There is not one review out yet for that model. John
Own Tisas 1911A1 .45acp, Girsan 6in long slide 10mm and a ATI 1911A1 .22LR. I love 1911s. IMO best pistols ever make. Also own Glocks, Berettas and several revolvers. I carry either the .45 or 10mm everyday. I don't buy over priced, expensive pistols because I don't treat them like a princess or have them as cabinet candy. I buy pistols that are reliable, 1911s have proven that. May be a little bias, 23year retired Navy and the 1911 was my sidearm.
I have a RIA 3.5 inch barrel in GI Series. Changed out the grips with a set of rosewood with a grim reaper motif, and added a dab of white nail polish to the front sight. I run Monarch steel 230 grain ammo. I keep it lubed with CRC Powerlube so far so good. Over 500 rounds no malfunctions. It is my truck gun. I like this basic setup a lot.
I've owned an Rock Island armory GI edition 1911 probably 10 years now I probably put more than a 1000 rounds through it I've only had one issue and that was on a fairly hot day and the friend I was with knocked a cannon monster over and it won't up in the gun. Very reliable wouldn't say I'd ever win any competitions putting a tight group together but I'm gonna Put a hole in what I want to put a hole in. Recently stepped up and bought a Rock Island armory 1911 a2 chambered in 10 mm I live in a state that brown black and polar bears are a possibility the last one only if I go to the north end. 10 is a bit better in stopping them 45 great self defense not nessasarily that great of a bear country sidearm.
This 1911 is really special carried one for 10 yrs in the army Lots of memories and never let me down. I will get one for Xmas from me to me. Great informative article one of the best I ve read. Thanks
So this article is for those looking to spend $500 or less yet over half of these are closer to $1000 than they are to $500....thanks...thanks a lot.
My wife and I each have an ATI 1911 (she has a Military Model and I have a Commander style) and we love them. They shoot great and are very reliable. We also have an ATI GSG 1911-22 that is a joy to shoot for inexpensive target practice. All three are excellent guns that didn't cost an arm and a leg.
I own the Tisas(not Tisa sir) Carry and their M1911 A1 Service models,both in .45 acp,recently bought the Carry new(Commander is the common name for a 4.25" 1911).Bought the Service model,a Colt "Black Army" clone,used Ive put 3,800+ rounds thru ut since buying it,zero failures,accurate,smooth.Both guns as accurate as the hands shooting them.Imo Tisas makes a better 1911 in any model than RIA,who I agree make very good ones.Tisas has the best at budget prices,and then some.
......tisas doesnt have a ''2011" like RIA with the TAC ultra. they also dont have the B3-10 or what ever its called a 3 inch 10 round .45 mini 1911... nore do they have double stacked 1911... RIA wins in my opinion bro
Girsan 1911's have triggers that rival expensive 1911's. I have customized one and it now will shoot with top grade 1911's and looks the part. I know the tisas is turkish made as well and likely is very similar or perhaps the same gun as the girsan. I have a charles daly field grade as well and have shot many a ria. Ria may make a bunch more options but i'm yet to shoot a ria thats a better gun than the turkish made 1911's.
anyone have feeding issues with their budget 1911? Buy sig sauer mags(trim base if necessary) and be amazed the problem is solved, the sig mags keep the bullets from nosing down and tilt the rounds at a slightly higher angle. My girsan (customized) Tuned 24lb wilson spring with the sig sauer mags eats all and every ammo type with zero failures to feed and zero ejection problems even with the stock ejector. My barrel is a rock river arms stainless, a stainless slide stop, a stainless bushing a number 2 wilson combat barrel link and soon a custom cerakote two tone finish with night sights and g10 grips will be added. The pistol is now just past the 700 dollar mark and i shoot round for round with several high dollar 1911's every bit as accurately.
SIG C3 ...... Enough said.
MD Vickery...I was "jus finna" say.... I have 1.5 words.... PARA.ORDNANCE. Son. Son son. Son son son. Mane.
I am a 1911 fan. I have had several and finally tried and purchased a Kimber Pro 4" 9mm. Fantastic tigger pull, nice balance, fits great. It has the Crimson Trace Laser Grips - FANTASTIC option for self defense. Allows me a view of what is around the target plus I do not need to line up the sights - the laser shows me what the gun is aimed at. I keep a look out for good deal on a Sig P220 in 9mm to purchase - I have been told they are FANTASTIC.
Interesting that you would include both Remington and Para Ordnance. Especially since Para is no more (purchased by Remington, now who knows the result.) Plus the link provided is to an online used gun marketer. I cast NO aspersions on the gun, but question why it was included here.
Apparently article was regurgitated from 2019. Para has been out of business for several years. They are nice firearms, however. Waste of time reading outdated material.
Rock Island 10mm, STI Trojan .38 Super. Excellent values
I love my rock island armory 1911!
You have a cool job testing and reviewing firearms I am slightly envious .. thanks for the article . I was shopping for a budget 1911 to build as I wished for a daily carry piece . Was seriously considering a RIA, locally none were available , always sold out . Before I was able to source one I was offered a Remington R1 enhanced , Alabama built. Used but like new . I bought it and do not regret it .everything I wanted in a 1911 under 1,000 dollars . The only issue ive had is that the factory mag will not allow JHP ammo to feed . Picked up a couple Kimber pro tactical mags and problem solved . Thanks for the time you take in writing your articles I may not agree with you on a few things but I support you 1st amendment rights by exercising my 2nd . Keep it up looking forward to more of your reviews.
I have walther colt 1911 22 lr it was so cheap and itz so much fun to shoot I got it at a gun show for around 140 bucks along ti.e ago still shoot it almost every week
I have Taurus PT1911 in 45 and the gun feels really well made. I found the factory mags to be unreliable but once I swapped them for Wilson Combat mags the gun has been 100 percent reliable. I have a two tone version that I paid $600 for and IMHO that's hard to beat.
I have a Taurus PT1911 .45cal, an ATI 1911 Titan .45cal, and a Colt Gold Cup 1911 .22cal made by Walther Arms under license from Colt. I put Hogue rubber finger grove grips on all three and I love the way they feel in my hand and are comfortable to shoot. I did a trigger job on all three. The Taurus is a nail driver and an absolute dream to shoot. Those of you that are "gun snobs" and won't try one because of the Taurus name, need to take another look. Taurus quality has greatly improved over the last few years. The ATI Titan which is an Officer size was bought to fiddle around with (changing to a colt guide rod and spring and other things) to see how they worked. The .22cal was something I thought would be fun for me (and especially my wife) to shoot and it has been that. It is also a good training gun, being the same size but a little lighter than a full sized .45.
My Iver Johnson Eagle is my favorite 1911 I currently have. I had my gunsmith do a trigger job on it and it is very accurate. Shoots RN, SWC, and hollow points without any issues.
I have a RIA 1911 GI FS, a RIA Compact Officers 1911 (it came with skelotinized trigger), a Colt 1911 Government Combat with all the bells & whistles in stainless steel, 2 SR 1911's one in 9mm & one in .45acp. They're all great shooters surprisingly the RIA's function as well as any. To Alex: I believe Armscor makes RIA's.
fuck this I want a Armscor 1911 GI 9mm pistol but don't have the monet
I'm surprised that ATI FX45 1911s weren't brought up since, based on pricing I've done for a while, they're a tad bit cheaper than Rock Islands. There was a review I came across where a brand new ATI FX45 Military was shot-for-shot compared to a literal WWII surplus Colt 1911A1. The review actually had them pretty even in quality and performance, but the ATI was favored slightly for the larger rear sight than the OG 1911.
Btw I just bought an ATI and the first mod I did was the Magpul grips like in this review. I do have a quality issue with a crooked front blade sight, but I was already planning to replace that with a white dot. I just have to find a gunsmith to do it since I don't have the tools or faith in myself to do it right.
ATI is a very good 1911. They are slightly less expensive than RIA & both are made in the Philippines, I put white fingernail polish on the front sight. It works great for me!
Nice article, in my experience a fair look at the market as of 2019, for those of us with limited funds. I appreciated that you covered models that are actually available ( with the exception of the Palmetto (PSA) guns.) I want to pass along just my feeling that even after having great times with several of these affordable 1911s, I just had to have a gen-u-wine Colt. I settled on a Government Model Series 70 Colt "re-production," paid mid 800 dollars, and it's minus the original split collet bushing and the cool brown box. Now you get a normal 1911 bushing and a plastic box. Other than that , it appears and feels to be exactly like the one I owned in 1976. This comment is practically irrelevant, becuase it doesn't speak to getting a less expensive "shooter," but even though that's what I intended to get I fell for the marketing and hype and just had to have the "original." I hope you avoid this trap better than I did ! It's a really really nice pistol though, actually probably better made than the one I had in 1970s. Beware!!
Travis, I have a AMT -Galena Government model .45 cal. 1911 in stainless. What would a new one cost?
I've loved and had 1911's most of my life. I had an experience this past year that's left a bad taste in my mouth from 2 reputable company's.......Springfield and Browning. I've had 2 911 .380 Springfield's and 2 Black Label .380 Browning's. I say 2 of each as both of my first guns were sent back to the company's because of numerous malfunctions. Springfield and Browning both gave me new guns to replace the defective guns.......and, the 2nd guns were just as bad as the first ones I sent back. The 911 Springfield's and the Black Label Browning's were without a doubt the worse guns I've ever experienced......and, I've been shooting guns since my dad gave me my 1st b.b. gun at age 5. Stay away from 911 Springfield's and Browning Black Label .380's !
Being as a 1911 was the first weapon Uncle Sh!tty issued me in 1982, I will always own one. After owning 4 or 5, I've settled on a Springfield Armory "Loaded" in .45 acp. It's equipped with one of the Recover Tactical CC3P grip rails and I f'n love it. It's my bedside and when I absolutely have to deal with what's left of "humanity", I slide off the light and it still fits in my shoulder rig.
I don't want to flame you. Yes, 1911s can have horrible issues but so can Khar, Glock, Sig, etc. handguns and numerous other makers who produce polymer-framed handguns. I currently own 4 1911s and I've owned 4 others; Not a single one has EVER had an issue or malfunctioned in any way WHATSOEVER regardless of the ammo type I've used and NONE of them has cost me more than $850.00. The 4 I currently own are a Ruger 45ACP, a Citadel Officer's model 45ACP made by Rock Island Armory, a Rock Island 9mm/22TCM combo gun, and a Colt Civilian Model made in 1912! Even my old Colt is a workhorse that has never malfunctioned in any way whatsoever and that includes with its original pinned base-plate, lanyard loop 1912 magazine! Honestly, it drives me crazy when gun writers start trashing 1911s as unreliable.
Yes, I own numerous striker-fired, polymer-framed handguns. The truth is that I have owned several of these guns that had significant feed issues and other malfunctions. I have owned Glocks, Khars, and Smith and Wesson striker-fired guns that I got rid of because they were, to quote the article, "junk." However, unlike anti-1911 gun writers, I've never trashed polymer, striker-fired handguns en masse. On top of that, I have several of these "wonderguns" that cost more than my most expensive 1911 by $300.00. Instead of trashing an entire type of handgun, why not state the truth that ANY handgun can have issues regardless of the price point?!?!
I state all of the above to get to this point: my prefered carry handgun is my Ruger 1911 in .45ACP. I carry it more than any other handgun along with four mags in leather GI double mag pouches I bought from Numrich Gun Parts that are circa the Vietnam War. Yes, I carry several of my polymer wonder guns too but more often than not, I have my Ruger 1911 on my hip because it is completely reliable. On top of that, even though it is a full size 1911, it is easily concealed because is it so thin. My double-stack, plastic wonderguns are nowhere near as concealable with the exception of my Walther PPS 40 S&W which holds fewer rounds!
In short, stop trashing an entire class of handguns just because you don't like them! You are no different that the jerks who trash revolvers and/or polymer-frame handguns "in toto" simply because they don't like them either.
Very well said David. I have carried a 1911 since first being introduced to the platform by the USMC in 1983. It is still my preferred combat handgun. As strong as my love of the 1911 is, unfortunately I cannot claim to have never had a malfunction. I purchased a brand-new Springfield Armory GI 1911 in ~1986 that failed on the 27th round through the weapon. The fire control system just locked-up solid. I took it to a gunsmith who found that a burr of metal in the mainspring housing tunnel had broken-off and jammed the mainspring, leaving the weapon useless. While this lack of QC in the manufacturing/assembly process did not put me off of the 1911 in general, I have never since, and will never again, purchase a Springfield 1911. At the same time, I have owned several Glocks, and have never had a single malfunction with any of them, yet I still prefer carrying a 1911.
Rugers nough said, my 1911 got to be made in the US
Hey not sure if you knew, but 1911s come in different forms than large low cap steel framed pistols. Some have polymer or alloy frames, some are double stacked magazines, some use 9mm, 40, 45, 10mm, and probably a couple others, and I'm not really sure what you mean about "not modular" but in my definition of modular but I've considered 1911s to be the most modular firearms out there.
You should check out some of the different configurations for the 1911! What you're saying is the same as considering all striker fired pistols to have low capacity or to be unreliable because Kahr makes a single stack low cap ammo-sensitive pistol.
Overall the 1911 is in my opinion an more reliable, proven, safer, more enjoyable platform than any other, especially striker guns! To discount a platform only because it's been around a long time is silly!
Do you have any recommendations on affordable 10mm 1911s? I’m in the market for one but I’m having trouble finding a good list of all the available 10mm options.
My top pick would be the Dan Wesson Bruin in burnt bronze...but it is decidedly NOT budget friendly lol.
Best budget option I'd pick the Rock Island Armory ROCK Ultra in 10mm. Retailing at around $680, not a bad price for a 1911 in 10mm.
RIA is also good to go, I own one of their normal .45 ACP 1911s and love it, their CS is also tops.
The Ruger SR1911 , model 6739 https://ruger.com/products/sr1911/specSheets/6739.html , is a government size (5” barrel) in 10mm that can be purchased for ~$800 + tax and fees, which for all of its features (all stainless, Bomar fully adjustable rear sight, lightweight aluminum trigger, beavertail grip safety, etc.) is a great price. It also has a bull barrel and a full-length guide rod, both of which add weight to the muzzle helping to mitigate recoil. The barrel also has a Wilson/Nowlin ramp to fully support the case and improve feeding reliability. The plunger tube is an integral part of the frame, so no worries about it shooting loose with full-power 10mm loads. Add the fact that it is made in the USA, and it is a great choice for a 10mm 1911.
I would say you are almost limited to Rock island on a budget 10mm. But that's not a bad thing. There may be something out there I missed when searching, but I landed on a tac ultra ms and I can't believe how tight that gun is for the money!
Best affordable 1911 IMHO is the Ruger SR1911.
Have you tried any of Rugers 1911s?
I have a .45 Commander, but they also make 9mm & 10mm 1911s.
I have a Talo Limited Edition Night Watchman. It is a Ruger SR1911 lightweight Commander with night sights, blackened stainless steel slide and black anodized aluminum frame. I paid $823 for it, out-the-door for it including tax, background check and transfer fee from a LGS. It is super accurate and reliable. Jeff Cooper said about the LW Commander: “it is a gun to be carried much, and shot little”, mainly due to the aluminum frame. LW Commanders had a reputation for the frame-ramp to get chewed-up by hollow point ammunition. Ruger solved this issue by installing a titanium insert in the frame; no more worries about damaging the frame by shooting hollowpoints!
Anytime there’s a negative article against a 1911 you can expect strong opinions in response... they are justified calling you out, the 1911 has proven itself for more then 100 years and still is a viable CCW choice... I bought my first Colt in 1984 and have never regretted the purchase... However, I also own Glock, CZ, striker Fire wonder weapons and I like them all..... they have their purpose and the Glocks and CZs are great guns... more of a tactical weapon, but we don’t always want tacticool weapons....
For myself I’ll take an old man gun where I carry my own flashlight and I can shoot well enough without a laser... I’m not a shootist, operator or expect... but within 10 yards I can protect myself... over 10 I’m running away or getting something else...
Your first statement that I have to take issue with is “the gun is nowhere near as modular as a modern handgun”. Four paragraphs later you write “the 1911 is almost as customizable as an AR-15”. So which is it? What modularity do “modern” handguns have that the 1911 doesn’t? Interchange backstraps to accommodate different hand sizes? On a 1911 you have a multitude of choices of mainspring housings (flat, arched, bobtail, round-butt, smooth, checkered, serrated, etc.), grip safeties ( GI, wide beavertail, narrowed “concealment” beavertail, Wilson, .250”, or .220” radius cut types, etc.), single side or ambidextrous thumb safeties with a plethora of lever styles, shapes and lengths, short, medium and long trigger pad lengths are available in different materials (steel, aluminum, nylon), face types (serrated, smooth). And let’s not forget the grips; available from ultra-slim to extra thick in every conceivable material from wood to G-10, aluminum, carbon fiber, laminates, the options are limitless.
All of the above features allow the 1911 shooter to tailor the weapon to fit their hand like no other pistol that I am aware of. So what is this modularity that “modern” handguns have that the 1911 doesn’t?
Modular and customizable are two different things. The SIG P320 is modular. I can swap a full size to a subcompact, I can;t do that with a 1911
So what?
Nice article. We are very fortunate here in Canada to have access to Norinco products. Their 1911 pistols are hard to beat on quality of steel and selection of features. They sell for < $400.00 Canadian and can be had as low as $300.00 on sale. While they do make basic GI models and shorter commanders, others are available as well with Ambi safety, extended beavertail, skeletinized trigger and hammer, and different sights. Mine is satin chrome, 5" barrel, ambi, with three dot fully adjustable sight. Accuracy is great, it eats everything; factory and all different kinds and shapes of home-loads. Best accuracy for me is with 200gr. SWC uncoated lead. The quality and hardness of the steel is second to none, and everyone's clips fit and function perfectly.
Finish wise, they are no Wilson, but with a little polishing, the sharp edges disappear, and after a few hundred rounds, the smooth right out.
There are some kicking around in the US before their importation was blocked (Clinton) I think; and the few I have seen when I travel there, even well used, often sell for more than they do new in Canada.
Mark, one of my several 1911s (and still one of my favorites) is a Norinco 1911A1 Government Model that I bought new sometime around 1991. I believe that I paid a little over $300 + tax for it then. After dropping about $1,800 with Jim MacDonald of Mac’s .45 Shop fame, the only original Norinco parts left are the frame and the slide. “Mac” transformed it into one of the sweetest 1911s that I have ever had the pleasure of shooting. From the ramped and throated Bar-Sto Match Target barrel, Millett Custom Combat Low Profile adjustable sights melded into the slide that Mac flat-topped and serrated, Caspian beavertail grip safety, King’s 201a ambidextrous thumb safety (that Mac customized by narrowing the levers), Smith & Alexander flat checkered mag guide hand blended to match the hand-beveled magazine well, Videcki speed trigger with a perfect “glass rod breaking” 3# pull, the deepest, darkest, high-polished slide flats with matte blue top and flawless hard chrome frame, and too much more to list, I will put my custom Norinco against anything that Wilson, Ed Brown or any other 1911 ‘smith can build.
I read somewhere on line that the US Gov is releasing some old 1911's from their armory for sale to civilians.
Do you know where or how to get one?
http://thecmp.org/cmp_sales/1911-information/
ok, you picked some good choices, why did you pass over Metro Arms Corp, American Classic Commander 45ACP????? the build quality is beyond awesome.
Never shot it, or even seen one in person, so I don't know a lot about it.
This is the most poorly written article ever to show up on this blog. Just the typos and such... it's probably the end for us Pew Pew.
Feel free to point out any typos and we'll correct them.
Lol. Now you’re just trolling.
I have a S&W in 1911 and it feeds and functions flawlessly. I don't remember what I paid for it 600-700 I think as I got it on a S&W military/first responder sale. I got the 4" version and the fit and finish are great as well as the function. The author is correct in that these are not "cutting edge" pistols, but every gun enthusiast should own a 1911.
I think a Spingfield Parkerized 1911 at about $700 would have been a good fit for this article.
What Colt 1911 currently in production most closely resembles the traditional GI issued model?
Thanks
Sean
Sean, the Colt Series 70 Government https://colt.com/detail-page/colt-70-govt-45-acp-5-71-double-diamond-rosewood-grip-blued is the current production Colt model that most closely matches the 1911 that was issued to U.S. Armed Forces for 75 years. There have been other, limited production and/or commemorative models in the past that were for all intensive purposes identical to USGI 1911s.
Thanks Michael
I wasn’t sure if the 70 or 1991 was “closer” to the early GI models.
Thanks again.
Magnum Research G1911 is an outstanding firearm. Paid $650.00 at my local gun shop. This dealer has great credentials and told me that this gun is the best kept secrets on the market. Sales pitch.??? No way. When I went to the range to test fire, it shot just as good as my “worked” Colt and SA 1911,s It is a Series 70 and super accurate out of the box.
I'm a fan of Magnum Research, but never got to handle one of their 1911s. I would love to though.
Good article with the benefit of reminding me that RIA has the 22 TCM. I do agree, the RIA GI is a great gun. I did equip it with a grip laser as it is my home defense gun when in my home office. I have no doubt it will go bang every time and, at $399, it was an absolute deal!
Once I relocate to a more friendly environment, the TCM is on my list. Especially since it has the conversion kit for 9mm.
As for more expensive 1911s, I have a few. They are all great. Only my Kimber Custom II has ever had a fail to go into battery. The Sig Saur and the Springfield, so far, have not had any problems.
As for relevance. The 1911s are still among the most ergonomic hand guns I have ever fired. I do have a couple of Glocks, but the ergonomics (at least for me) are not that great. The closes fits, for me, are the XD and the ultra heavy Ruger P90.
Thank you for the article and Semper Fi!
Sgt Sgt Allen (And yes, there is a bit of a story on that).
You've never run into a bad Taurus automatic? Have you ever seen one? There was a class action suit involving hundreds of thousands of them. They are trash. They break at completely random times for no discernible reason. Take it from the owner of one, who also knows the owners of other broken Taurus automatics. Try to use the warranty, you might get your gun back in 9 months. They might fix it, they might ship it back just as you sent it. They might tell you they're substituting a different model and caliber from what you sent in, because that's their policy.
We really have say it's SEMI-automatic? As you've experienced, I've avoided Taurus products because of the inconsistent quality and problems friends & family have had.
How about the norinco 1911?
Travis,
Great article, and I totally agree with your assessment of the 1911. They are great guns! They are also a step in-between the revolver and the modern combat pistol.
I've carried one on patrol over the years, but that was a while ago.
Sean